OpenSSL Communities

Question for the BAC: Does the BAC recommend that UPKI goes on the roadmap, and for 4.2?

Jeff Johnson PublicSeen by 7

A request has come in that is a BAC question: UPKI (better certificate revocation) in OpenSSL, targeting 4.2.

Dmitry posted it in the TAC, and the Board reviewed it (the Board's reply). After talking it through, the Board decided it should come to it as a recommendation from the BAC, with the TAC's technical view next to it.

The evidence of support:

The LBC poll asked "UPKI or CT, if only one," so it is not a direct yes/no on UPKI.

There seems to be a consensus from the OS distributions and Large Business communities that UPKI should be added to OpenSSL.

The TAC will provide the technical implementation information.

So the direct question for the BAC is:

Does the BAC recommend that UPKI goes on the roadmap, and for 4.2?

Would the BAC like a poll or is a discussion here good enough?

thx,

-jj

Paul Yang

The answer from me is: Yes, UPKI should goes into the roadmap and 4.2

Paul Yang

And I don't mind a poll here but I also don't think it's very necessary🤔

Anton Arapov

Thanks, @Jeff Johnson; and thanks to everyone who fed into this: the Distributions and Large Business communities, whose polls gave a clear read, and Paul for the quick yes.

This is exactly what the BAC is here to weigh in on - the “what”: does better certificate revocation (UPKI) belong on the OpenSSL roadmap? That’s a business-and-community call, and the signal is strong.

On that basis, the Board has reviewed the request and agrees: UPKI should go on the roadmap. Our engineers will look into it, and we welcome the TAC to lead on the “how” - the technical design and implementation.

On 4.2 specifically: we’ve heard the ask. Whether UPKI can land in that release is part of the technical scoping, so I’d treat 4.2 as the target to work toward rather than a firm commitment today - the engineering and TAC assessment will tell us.

We’d also like the wider community to stay involved on the “how”: if you have views on how UPKI should be implemented, please share them here or in the TAC thread, and we’ll genuinely weigh them as the work takes shape.

On the poll question - given the Board’s agreement and the support already on record, I don’t think one’s needed to proceed, but if the BAC wants to record a formal recommendation, that’s the BAC’s call.

Thanks again for driving this.